#illegality

11.09.2025 11:45

Change in the composition of the Commission on the Higher Civil Service Corps

Can a person who has been excluded from the Commission on the Higher Civil Service Corps appeal this decision in court if he or she considers it illegal?

Read full question
30.08.2025 09:10

Does a serviceman have the right to refuse to carry out a commander's order?

I recently learned about a case where a soldier was unable to carry out an order from his commander due to health reasons and was acquitted by a court. I wonder if a soldier can refuse to carry out an order at all if he considers it illegal or dangerous to his life or health?

Read full question

Similar questions

29.08.2025 16:05

Appointment of members of the High Council of Justice

What criteria should be taken into account when appointing members of the High Council of Justice under the President's quota to ensure their independence and objectivity?

Read full question
10.09.2025 17:10

Resumption of civil service competitions

Do you think the resumption of competitions for civil service positions from June 1, 2026 will be an effective mechanism for selecting qualified personnel?

Read full question
24.08.2025 08:05

Competition for the positions of members of the Competition Commission

I want to participate in the competition for the position of a member of the Competition Commission for the Selection of Members of the Supreme Judicial Council. Do I have the right to submit documents if I am a judge of a commercial court, but do not work in Kyiv or Odessa?

Read full question
22.09.2025 07:50

Updating the judicial corps

If the High Council of Justice plans to renew the judicial corps by a third within two years, does this mean that I will be able to appeal the decision of a judge who will be elected during this renewal, using the same procedures as the decisions of other judges?

Read full question
14.07.2023 18:38

What changes did the council make to Art. 71 of the Central Committee?

Read full question
05.09.2025 13:05

Can a serviceman appeal the actions of a commander?

If a serviceman believes that a commander is illegally demanding a bribe or violating his rights, can he challenge these actions in court?

Read full question
21.07.2023 18:54

Does the commander have the right to check the parcels that came to me?

He opened all the boxes, broke things. Maybe he stole something, I don't know, there was no description of the parcels.

Read full question
23.06.2023 14:30

What is the punishment if I refuse to carry out a combat order...

What is the punishment if I refuse to perform a combat mission?

Read full question
24.11.2025 12:25

Responsibility of a serviceman for refusal to obey an order

Can a serviceman avoid criminal liability for refusing to obey an order during martial law if he was in a state of psychological breakdown as a result of participation in combat operations?

Read full question
29.09.2025 10:40

Does a serviceman have the right to refuse to carry out an order?

I am a military member and have received an order that I believe is against the law. Do I have the right to refuse to carry it out? What are the consequences for me if I refuse?

Read full question