Do you think the results of the qualification testing on general knowledge in the field of law and knowledge on the specialization of the local general court are objective, if 4,489 people out of 6,754 participants who passed the testing were admitted to the third stage of the qualification exam?
The High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine has published the coded results of the testing of general knowledge in the field of law and knowledge of the specialization of the local general court. Does a test participant have the right to appeal his results if he believes that the assessment was conducted with violations? What appeal procedures are there?
I am interested in whether the practice of regular evaluation of judges, which the HQCJ plans to introduce, contradicts the principles of judicial independence and whether it can affect the objectivity of judicial decisions? Is this evaluation considered legal from the point of view of Ukrainian legislation?
If I want to become a local court judge, do I need to take a cognitive ability test if I already have 5 years of experience as a lawyer?
I am interested in the question: if a judge successfully passed the qualification assessment during the competition for the position of a judge of the court of appeal, is he considered to be suitable for the position held in accordance with paragraph 20 of Section XII of the Law of Ukraine 'On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges'?
Do you think it meets the requirements of the law and ensures impartiality for representatives of public associations to evaluate a judge's "knowledge of the case" during the consideration of a case without being familiar with the details of the case?
If the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine has not confirmed the suitability of a judge for the position held, does the High Council of Justice have the right to cancel the decision of the HQCJ on submitting a petition for dismissal from the position held?
I am interested in whether it is possible to appeal the decision of the High Qualification Commission of Judges regarding the admission of candidates to perform a practical task during the selection for the positions of judges of local courts? What are the grounds and procedure for such an appeal?
I am wondering whether it is possible to appeal the decision of the High Qualification Commission of Judges on the suitability of a judge for the position held in court if the decision was made in violation of the qualification assessment procedure?
I am trying to participate in the competition for the position of judge of the Supreme Court of Cassation, but I have questions about the procedure for conducting the competition. Is it possible to appeal the decision of the HQCJ regarding the competition for the position of judge, and if so, how?
I am a judge and I am wondering if it is possible to appeal the decision of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine regarding the motivation of its decisions if I consider them insufficiently substantiated. I have heard that experts will train members of the HQCJ to properly motivate their decisions, but what to do with decisions that have already been made?
I am trying to become a judge and would like to know if there is a possibility to appeal the decision of the High Qualification Commission of Judges regarding the admission of candidates to cognitive ability testing if I believe that violations were committed during this process?