25.08.2025 08:05
Legal position in the case of a military serviceman
If a serviceman has health problems and cannot carry out a commander's order, will he be held liable for failure to comply with the order?
Read full question
#commander's order
30.08.2025 09:10
Does a serviceman have the right to refuse to carry out a commander's order?
I recently learned about a case where a soldier was unable to carry out an order from his commander due to health reasons and was acquitted by a court. I wonder if a soldier can refuse to carry out an order at all if he considers it illegal or dangerous to his life or health?
Read full question
Similar questions
05.09.2025 13:05
Can a serviceman appeal the actions of a commander?
If a serviceman believes that a commander is illegally demanding a bribe or violating his rights, can he challenge these actions in court?
Read full question
21.07.2023 18:54
Does the commander have the right to check the parcels that came to me?
He opened all the boxes, broke things. Maybe he stole something, I don't know, there was no description of the parcels.
Read full question
23.06.2023 14:30
What is the punishment if I refuse to carry out a combat order...
What is the punishment if I refuse to perform a combat mission?
Read full question
24.11.2025 12:25
Responsibility of a serviceman for refusal to obey an order
Can a serviceman avoid criminal liability for refusing to obey an order during martial law if he was in a state of psychological breakdown as a result of participation in combat operations?
Read full question
29.09.2025 10:40
Does a serviceman have the right to refuse to carry out an order?
I am a military member and have received an order that I believe is against the law. Do I have the right to refuse to carry it out? What are the consequences for me if I refuse?
Read full question
28.08.2025 07:50
Military personnel and the law
Do you think it is necessary to establish a special procedure for recognizing military personnel as missing during martial law, and will this change the lives of the families of missing military personnel?
Read full question
12.09.2025 16:00
Legal position
Do you consider it fair to limit the amount of judicial remuneration based on the 'frozen' subsistence minimum of 2,102 hryvnias, if the actual subsistence minimum for able-bodied persons in 2025 is 3,028 hryvnias?
Read full question
20.09.2025 13:50
Can the actions of the military personnel in this case be considered legal?
Three servicemen in the Kyiv region sold fuel from their unit, causing losses of $23 thousand. They were reported on suspicion of large-scale embezzlement of diesel fuel. How can I qualify the actions of these individuals according to the law?
Read full question
13.08.2025 13:38
Is a military serviceman subject to criminal liability?
What if, as a result of improper performance of duties regarding the defense of Ukraine, a breakthrough of Russian troops was allowed near Dobropillya?
Read full question
26.08.2025 13:25
Military service and the law
If a serviceman receives payments without reason during martial law, do I have the right to compensation for the damage caused, if I reported this to the relevant authorities?
Read full question